New Buffalo cottage rentals

Book one of our 153 cottage rentals and start making plans for your trip to New Buffalo. Whether you’d like to be in Gordon Beach, Michiana, Tryon Farm or another in-demand area, these cozy and charming cottages offer more room to move compared to a hotel.

Check out our cottage rental listings in New Buffalo for a good idea of costs. If you want to make some savings, try our “Discounts” filter. It’ll display any cottages featuring special promotions, whether that’s a weekly, monthly or new listing discount.

It all comes down to how much you want to spend, what kind of weather you like and if you prefer the energy of peak season or a more relaxing vibe. Located in Harbour Country, June is the most popular month to visit New Buffalo, with the average temperatures ranging between 59ºF (15ºC) and 71ºF (22ºC). Have a look at the availability of our cottage rentals at different times of the year and then make your choice.

Let the stresses fade away as you unwind and stare at the beach views from your cozy cottage rental in New Buffalo. Make use of our filter tools to look for cottages with outdoor areas, such as a patio or deck, so you can enjoy the scenic beauty even more.

For a refreshing and relaxing escape, it’s hard to top our lakeside cottage rentals. Try our “Location” filter and then click on “Lake” to see if you can find any cozy properties that’ll put you near the water in New Buffalo. Spend your days chasing outdoor adventures or just enjoy the gorgeous sunrises and sunsets shimmering across the lake.

Arrange a few day trips from your cottage rental, making sure to include Warren Dunes State Park, Washington Park Beach and Warren Dunes State Park Beach. These leading New Buffalo attractions are family friendly, so everyone can come along.

Whether at the foot of a mountain or along the beachfront, Vrbo’s cottage rentals will put you exactly where you’d like to be. Finding your perfect stay is a cinch when you use our filters to search by things like nearby attractions, amenities and budget. Besides getting the whole cottage rental to yourselves, our cancellation policies take the hassle out of booking. Additionally, our One Key™ loyalty platform lets you collect and use OneKeyCash™* on all eligible bookings on Vrbo, Hotels.com and Expedia. *OneKeyCash disclaimer - OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Vrbo, Expedia and Hotels.com.